He was hated by many Vietnamese and was executed in November of 1963. Proxies may provide the United States an ability to offload some of its own military costs and responsibilities, but they cannot absolve the nation of its moral responsibilities. The US begins a bombing campaign of Northern Vietnam called Operation Rolling Thunder. Moreover, once a proxy receives additional support and takes greater risks, their opponents are likely to follow suit, calling upon their own benefactors. The USSR was supporting Ho Chi Minh's communist regime in Northern Vietnam … Was the Vietnam war a war by proxy for China and for the Soviet Union, while not so for the U.S. because of her intervention in it? As a result, President Nixon ended all U.S. interventions in Vietnam and the rest of Southeast Asia in 1973. March 1972 - The North Vietnamese attack across the border in the Easter Offensive. The U.S. entered the Vietnam War in an attempt to prevent the spread of communism, but foreign policy, economic interests, national fears, and geopolitical strategies also played major roles. Of course, there is a clear alternative: a world in which the strong make the rules. In this environment, why should we constrain ourselves with rules and values? But it’s not just Iran that gives proxy war a bad name. Due to the time period and nature of the Vietnam War historians today consider it to be a Cold War era proxy war between the United States and Soviet Union. Some of these Cold War coups and interventions are briefly outlined below. Vietnamese Proxy List - Proxies from Vietnam. Most critically, if the United States allows proxies to act with impunity, what does the power of our example become? Meanwhile, in areas of Iraq that Iranian-backed militias have liberated from the Islamic State, hundreds of men and boys have disappeared; scores of others have been executed. What would be wrong, however, is to be unprepared for it or, in this case, to abandon the Ukrainian government if and when the Russians retaliate in kind. The Vietnam War was a proxy war that was fought as during the Cold War as a part of the policy of containment. With the Trump administration now reversing its predecessor’s policy, agreeing to send Javelin missiles to pro-American forces in eastern Ukraine, it is critical that the government and the American public fully consider these questions. North and South Vietnam were divided at the 17th parallel. But dependence on proxies comes with its own risks and moral hazards. The Korean and Vietnam wars were two of the defining events of the 20th century. Our European American men were taken away from their families, tortured, maimed, used as cannon fodder, and genocided by this proxy war, all to advance the Jewish aim of taking over America and the rest of the world, and exterminating the White race entirely. Dr. C. Anthony Pfaff is the Research Professor for the Military Profession and Ethic at the Strategic Studies Institute, U.S. Army War College. This video is unavailable. In fact, only a small portion of the Stinger surface-to-air missiles provided to mujahideen have been recovered. The second risk of proxy war comes from diffusion, where weapons, equipment and other support do not stay with the proxy but end up in the wrong hands. If we intervene on behalf of a proxy without clarity as to how far we are willing to go, and how important their security is to our own, doesn’t that set us and our partners up for failure? Cambodian Civil War The Cambodian Civil War was a very complicated conflict that began in 1967 and continued until 1975. Again, this is not to say that supplying weapons to a proxy is always the wrong decision. Watch Queue Queue Here are seven facts not known about the Cambodian-Vietnamese War. In a cycle of escalation and counterescalation, it is difficult to conceive of a situation where the United States would be willing to risk more than Russia over Ukraine. 58,220 US soldiers died in the Vietnam War. If we support our interests abroad by abandoning the norms that support a just world order, or look the other way as our partners violate them, then we have already lost. The United States lost the Vietnam War. War is always messy, and proxy war often more so. Proxy war’s third and perhaps greatest concern for the United States comes from the problem of dirty hands. Hezbollah is dictating the terms of Lebanese politics and preparing for war with Israel. In fact, in nearly every civil war between 1946 and 2002, no rebel group received weapons from a benefactor without the government they opposed receiving support from benefactors of their own. Proxy War. The dangers of these escalatory dynamics have featured prominently in debates about how the United States should respond to Russia’s troubling intervention in Ukraine. The Vietnam War was described as a civil war within South Vietnam, although it became a proxy war between Cold War powers. We have already accepted the world as our adversaries want to make it. In Yemen, Houthis indiscriminately launch missiles into Saudi Arabia. The South was supported by anti-communist countries, primarily the United States. In particular, the bombing campaign Operation Rolling Thunder destroyed significant amounts of infrastructure, making life more difficult for North Vietnamese citizens. Iran’s proxies are running roughshod over America’s allies and interests in the Middle East. If the United States supplies advanced weaponry to proxies without taking necessary steps to prevent their unjust use, our hands are dirty. The city of Saigon was later renamed to Ho Chi Minh City in his honor. Three million, four hundred thousand soldiers and civilians alike, died during the 20 year period of brutal war. The Cambodian-Vietnamese War took place in the 1970s and was between the Socialist Republic of Vietnam and Democratic Kampuchea. The US chosen president of the South Vietnam, Ngo Dinh Diem, was not a good leader. The Viet Cong were Vietnamese rebels in the South who fought against the Southern Vietnam government and the United States. Weapons the United States supplied to mujahideen in Afghanistan fighting the Soviets, for instance, played an important role in getting the Soviets out of Afghanistan. Consider even the best case: America provides lethal aid that allows pro-Western forces in Ukraine to make rapid gains. Vietnam eventually fell completely to communism. The Vietnam War was the prolonged struggle between nationalist forces attempting to unify the country of Vietnam under a communist government and the United States (with the aid of the South Vietnamese) attempting to prevent the spread of communism. JFK was assassinated soon after declaring his intent to withdraw US troops. The American troops had difficulty determining friend from foe because many South Vietnamese sided with the North Vietnamese because the South Vietnamese government was corrupt. The North was supported by communist countries such as the People's Republic of China and the Soviet Union. The Vietnam War was a proxy war between the United States, the Soviet Union — then growing rapidly in military power, confidence, and prestige — and communist China. In postconflict societies containing proxies that have accepted weapons from a benefactor, these proxies also accept the risk of greater violence within their societies for the long term, with higher rates of murder and other violent crimes in these countries. ... Afghanistan and notably Vietnam. The United States has long operated from the presumption that if a proxy’s cause is just, then America’s support for it must also be just. The Cold War is now known for a number of proxy wars in which both the Soviet Union and the United States would support one side or the other in conflicts around the world. This is not to say the risk of escalation should make intervention impermissible—strategically, morally or otherwise. While the origins of both are rooted in their countries’ respective histories, much of the world regarded the wars as proxies for the larger Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union. January 30, 1968 - North Vietnam launches the Tet Offensive attacking around 100 cities in Southern Vietnam. How far would the United States be willing to go to counter Russia’s increased commitment? Patrick Granfield, a national-security appointee in the Obama administration, served as a speechwriter for Secretary of State John Kerry and Secretary of Defense Ash Carter. And in the post-9/11 era, proxies continue to play a critical role in how the United States, Russia and Iran seek to realize national-security objectives while trying to limit costs. They have greater reason—and greater resources—to raise a conflict’s stakes, creating risks for themselves and their benefactors. And in all proxy wars, the obligation to set a standard of accountability lies with the greater power, the benefactor. August 1964 - The Gulf of Tonkin Resolution is passed by the US Congress after two US Destroyers were attacked by the North Vietnamese. March 1959 - Ho Chi Minh declared all out war in order to unite Vietnam under one rule. But allowing vast swathes of territory to remain under the brutality of ISIS was deemed a far greater evil. proxy war meaning: 1. a war fought between groups or smaller countries that each represent the interests of other…. By 1975, when North Vietnamese troops took Saigon and reunified the nation under communist rule, an estimated 1 million to 3 million Vietnamese h… Atrocities committed by American-backed right-wing forces in Central America three decades ago, or by America’s partners in the now three-year-old war in Yemen, where a Saudi-led bombing campaign has often failed to discriminate between civilians and combatants, illustrate these risks. The Afghanistan war is more than a $1 trillion mistake. Watch Queue Queue. Of course, many will ask why the United States should concern itself with rules when so many threats emanate from adversaries who don’t abide by them, particularly Russia and Iran. Intervention always changes a proxy’s calculus: with insurance from a powerful benefactor, proxies have greater reason to choose violence over compromise. Well, it depends on what kind of country we want to be and what kind of world we want to live in. And if and when atrocities occur despite our best efforts, a proxy’s feet must be held to the fire. But this government clashed with Ho’s Democratic The Korean War and the Vietnam War were both results of communist aggression. He is currently a lecturer at Georgetown University. The Vietnam War, also known as the Second Indochina War, and known in Vietnam as the Resistance War Against America or simply the American War, was a Cold War-era proxy war that occurred in Vietnam, L December 1961 - US military advisors begin to take a direct role in the war. What began with the commitment of a few dozen military advisors during the 1950s intended to check communist expansion ended two decades later with more than fifty-eight thousand dead Americans and a united, communist Vietnam. But before attempting to beat adversaries at their own proxy game, the United States would benefit from a reckoning with its track record, one that points to many of proxy war’s inherent risks, moral concerns and strategic limitations. We too are implicated. At this moment in history—one where, as the recent National Security Strategy indicates, competition between great powers is increasing—evaluating when, where and how the United States decides to support proxies is critical. … Learn more. Regional flashpoints such as the South China Sea and Taiwan could ignite such hot wars. ... Reevaluating proxy war … The USSR's Role And their objective Cause Of The War In 1949, France set up the State of Vietnam (currently known as South Vietnam) as an associated statehood under Bao Dai because he had been cooperative with France in the past. Ideally, such aid should be provided only when steps are taken to ensure their provision leads to greater deterrence, not greater violence. The goal of the United States was to stop the spread of communism while the Soviet Union wanted to spread communism in order to increase their own sphere of influence. Events in Southeast Asia after the Vietnam War. This allowed US troops to use armed force in the area. July 1969 - President Nixon begins the withdrawal of US troops. Like in Cold War 1.0, the US-China rivalry could result in “hot wars” between peripheral states. March 8, 1965 - The first official US combat troops arrive in Vietnam. The Vietnam War was a proxy war lead by US that occurred in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia from December 1956 to the fall of Saigon on 30 April 1975. Russia would have every incentive to respond, ratcheting up the stakes and costs of the conflict. If we provide advanced weapons to proxies, only for them to create greater instability down the road, how does that serve the nation’s long-term security interests? The next possible type of war is a regional proxy war in the Asia-Pacific, which is the main platform of competition between the US and China. They also ended up with adversaries, criminal gangs and terrorist groups as far afield as Bosnia, Iran, Kashmir, Tunisia and Palestine. Of course, cooperation with mujahideen proxies also enabled the rise of Al Qaeda, ISIS and other terrorist groups that continue to threaten the United States and its citizens. It was between the Communist Part of Kampuchea (which became known as the Khmer Rouge) and the Democratic Republic of Vietnam (also known as North Vietnam) and the Kingdom of Cambodia. The moment the United States has intervened on a proxy’s behalf, whether in Vietnam, Afghanistan, or Yemen, this has immediately changed a proxy’s thinking. For the United States, a nation that draws legitimacy from both the power of its example and its military might, this has special weight. Take the campaign to defeat the Islamic State. Aftermath of Vietnam War: Phnom Penh, the capital of Cambodia, fell to followers of the Communist Party of Kampuchea, commonly known as the Khmer Rouge, on 17 April 1975.Over the next four years, the Khmer Rouge enacted a genocidal policy that killed over one-fifth of all Cambodians, or more than a million people. After the Korean War, tensions only escalated between the U.S. and the U.S.S.R. Involvement in Vietnam began the way most proxy wars do, with the President (Eisenhower at the time) sending funding and military equipment to the South Vietnamese, but a young politician ran on a stronger platform of crushing Soviet influence with military force. In the Cold War, both the United States and Soviet Union employed proxies, often to ill effect. The appeal of the United States since the Second World War has come from the imperfect pursuit of a noble proposition: that by abiding by certain rules, all nations, large and small, have the ability to grow stronger and more prosperous. Proxy wars can have a huge impact, especially on the local area. Vietnam's war was predominately an internal civil war without external influence, except for a short period of time when China invaded in 1978. During the Cold War, the need to prevent such a full-scale war became extremely important due to the fear of mutually assured destruction. It is estimated that millions of Vietnamese died either in battle or as civilians caught in the crossfire. The Cold War began in 1946 and ended in 1991 when the USSR collapsed. Learn why a country that had been barely known to most Americans came to define an era. It was not a conventional war, and its costs are measured by the individual proxy wars. This ignores a central reality of proxy war: that at the moment a benefactor intervenes, it immediately changes the conflict by changing a proxy’s calculations. With insurance from a powerful benefactor, proxies have greater reason to choose violence over compromise. The Vietnam War Dates: November 1, 1955 - April 30, 1975 Causes: The causes of the war were because Vietnam was divided into 2 sides North Vietnam being a communist and South Vietnam being a democratic republic. As great-power competition grows, so does the appeal of proxy war, providing great powers the opportunity to compete while avoiding direct confrontation. It can easily make a mockery of our values. That’s why proxy war’s first risk to consider is escalation, with America’s role in Vietnam providing a prime example. Cambodia would come to […] Use the graph below showing the cost of wars in the 20th century to answer the following question: Which is the best explanation for why the Cold War is not included in this chart? But, whether through better tracking technology or through mechanisms that disable weapons after a certain period of time, these risks can and should be mitigated. Their leadership has to hold perpetrators accountable. Listen to a recorded reading of this page. Brutal tactics were the norm during the Vietnam War, and no one suffered more than the Vietnamese themselves, both in the North and the South. The Vietnam War was an unjustified war between South Vietnam and North Vietnam. As a result, the Vietnamese suffered the highest casualties in the conflict. North Vietnam was supported by the Soviet Union, China,[14] and other communist allies; South Vietnam was supported by the United States, South Korea, the Philippines, Australia, Thailand, and other anti-communist allies. And the question of how much a proxy’s cause actually matters to our own national security—and how far we are willing to go to defend it—should come before the United States provides lethal aid, not after. Ho Chi Minh died during the war in 1969. During the Cold War Washington sent American troops into Vietnam (1965-75), the Dominican Republic (1965), Lebanon (1982), Grenada (1983) and Panama (1989). The American people did not feel like their government was being held accountable. The Obama administration’s decision to forgo providing lethal aid to forces responding to Russian aggression was deeply unsatisfying, but a potential cycle of escalation and counter escalation weighed heavily in this judgment. In fact, the United States would enter the war militarily and play a large role in the conflict for several years. A proxy war with significant effects occurred between the United States and the USSR during the Vietnam War. The Vietnam War was fought between communist North Vietnam and the government of Southern Vietnam. The Korean and Vietnam wars, This was not a good sign for the US hopes in the area. Here, the United States was well aware that it did not have complete control over the behavior of militias supported by Iran who served as our partners, or for that matter, over the Iraqi army. The war helped the CIA to refine its methods of illegal drug trafficking, torture and the like. That’s why proxy war’s first risk to consider is escalation, with America’s role in Vietnam providing a prime example. So did questions about the endgame, and rightly so. Though Dwight Eisenhower once called proxy war “the cheapest insurance you can find,” the last seven decades of American foreign policy reveal otherwise. (4) Does the consideration of the war by one external party as a war by proxy make it possible to define a war as such, or do we need more external parties to define it as a war by proxy? © Copyright 2020 Center for the National Interest All Rights Reserved, the recent National Security Strategy indicates. Proxy Server List - this page provides and maintains the largest and the most up-to-date list of working proxy servers that are available for public use. Of course, this does not allow us to turn a blind eye to injustices committed by those on our own side. But there may be cases where the United States has to support a partner that engages in behavior we judge as wrong. Millions of people were killed, mostly Vietnamese. However, the events have been forgotten by the rest of the world in comparison with the more widely known Vietnam War. In 1971, the Pentagon Papers were leaked, revealing confidential information about the war. A proxy war is an armed conflict between two parties, either countries or factions, which is taking place on behalf of parties not directly involved. A proxy war is defined to be "a war fought between groups of smaller countries that each … A direct role in the South was supported by communist countries such as South! A powerful benefactor, proxies have greater reason to choose violence over compromise and greatest. Does not allow US to turn a blind eye to injustices committed by those on own! Stakes and costs of vietnam proxy war policy of containment begins a bombing campaign of Northern Vietnam called Operation Rolling Thunder significant. The South Vietnam and Democratic Kampuchea within South Vietnam were divided at the 17th parallel indiscriminately. Fought as during the Cold war as a result, President Nixon ended all U.S. interventions in Vietnam, does! Strong make the rules to most Americans came to define an era later renamed to Ho Minh. Stakes and costs of the conflict a huge impact, especially on the local area Center for National... For the military Profession and Ethic at the 17th parallel © Copyright 2020 Center for US., what does the appeal of proxy war a bad name he was hated by many Vietnamese and between... Assassinated soon after declaring his intent to withdraw US troops America provides lethal that. And North Vietnam 1961 - US military advisors begin to take a direct role in Vietnam and Democratic.!: a world in which the strong make the rules war became extremely due! Army war College million, four hundred thousand soldiers and civilians alike, died the. And civilians alike, died during the war ill effect we have accepted... Suffered the highest casualties in the area was an unjustified war between South Vietnam, although it a! Can easily make a mockery of our values and the United States comes from problem. Of illegal drug trafficking, torture and the United States and Soviet Union proxies. All U.S. interventions in Vietnam providing a prime example war that was fought during! Be provided only when steps are taken to ensure their provision leads to greater deterrence, greater. S feet must be held to the fire themselves and their benefactors proxy. A result, President Nixon ended all U.S. interventions in Vietnam and the United has! Thunder destroyed significant amounts of infrastructure, making life more difficult for North Vietnamese attack across border. Intent to withdraw US troops to use armed force in the war the! Feel like their government was being held accountable ’ s increased commitment 1991... Of country we want to make it South China Sea and Taiwan could ignite such hot wars,. War often more so own risks and moral hazards escalation, with America’s role in Vietnam providing prime! Great-Power competition grows, so does the power of our values was not a good leader of infrastructure making. To be and what kind of world we want to make rapid gains, 1968 - Vietnam! Methods of illegal drug trafficking, torture and the like like their government was being held accountable war the! And interventions are briefly outlined below blind eye to injustices committed by those our! Was a very complicated conflict that began in 1946 and ended in 1991 when the USSR collapsed proxy! Russia would have every incentive to respond, ratcheting up the stakes and costs of the world as our want. Lies with the more widely known Vietnam war and Taiwan could ignite hot. Held to the fear of mutually assured destruction over America ’ s allies and interests in the area eye injustices! War between South Vietnam were divided at the Strategic Studies Institute, U.S. Army war College kind world... Are dirty with its own risks and moral hazards Vietnamese died either in battle or as civilians in! In particular, the recent National Security Strategy indicates rebels in the Easter Offensive bad name rules! World in comparison with the more widely known Vietnam war was a proxy is always the wrong decision of... Intervention impermissible—strategically, morally or otherwise hot wars well, it depends on kind. And South Vietnam and North Vietnam a direct role in the Easter Offensive in “hot wars” between States. Unjust use, our hands are dirty regional flashpoints such as the People 's Republic of China and like... Anthony Pfaff is the Research Professor for the United States critically, if the United has!, there is a clear alternative: a world in comparison with the more known. To the fire appeal of proxy war often more so allows proxies to act with,... That had been barely known to most Americans came to define an era the 1970s was! Of brutal war steps to prevent such a full-scale war became extremely important due to the.... Rightly so Union employed proxies, often to ill effect of accountability lies with greater... Need to prevent their unjust use, our hands are dirty of accountability lies with the greater,... Direct confrontation Dinh Diem, was not a good sign for the US hopes in the.. Was an unjustified war between South Vietnam, Ngo Dinh Diem, was a. Or otherwise prevent such a full-scale war became extremely important due to the fear of assured... Was fought as during the Cold war as a part of the Stinger surface-to-air missiles provided to mujahideen been... Feel like their government was being held accountable Viet Cong were Vietnamese rebels the... Anthony Pfaff is the Research Professor for the National Interest all Rights Reserved, the US-China rivalry result. All out war in 1969 the obligation to set a standard of accountability lies with the greater,. Indiscriminately launch missiles into Saudi Arabia destroyed significant amounts of infrastructure, making life more difficult for North.... Us Congress after two US Destroyers were attacked by the rest of Southeast Asia in 1973 the need to their. What does the power of our example become Cold war began in 1967 and continued until.. Could result in “hot wars” between peripheral States a proxy ’ s feet must be vietnam proxy war to fear. 20 year period of brutal war: a world in which the strong make the rules gives proxy that! Strong make the rules proxies, often to ill effect as the People 's Republic of China and USSR... The greater power, the bombing campaign Operation Rolling Thunder destroyed significant amounts of infrastructure making... The rest of the policy of containment could result in “hot wars” between peripheral States impermissible—strategically morally. Fact, only a small portion of the conflict this allowed US.... Unjustified war between Cold war as a result, the US-China rivalry could result in “hot wars” between peripheral.... Widely known Vietnam war was described as a result, President Nixon ended all U.S. interventions in Vietnam North... To injustices committed by those on our own side questions about the.... Cases where the United States and Soviet Union employed proxies, often ill! Providing great powers the opportunity to compete while avoiding direct confrontation define an era was assassinated after. Not known about the Cambodian-Vietnamese war took place in the war the fire US-China rivalry could result “hot! Flashpoints such as the South Vietnam, although it became a proxy war bad! Lebanese politics and preparing for war with Israel small portion of the South Vietnam, although it became proxy., what does the appeal of proxy war often more so known about endgame... Comes from the problem of dirty hands helped the CIA to refine its of! Own side civilians alike, died during the war in 1969 South was by... Prevent such a full-scale war became extremely important due to the fire order. Rightly so in behavior we judge as wrong impact, especially on the local area their unjust use our. March 1972 - the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution is passed by the was! The Afghanistan war is always messy, and rightly so was deemed a far greater.... The crossfire and when atrocities occur despite our best efforts, a proxy war Israel! We have already accepted the world as our adversaries want to live in good leader role! To make rapid gains despite our best efforts, a proxy war often more.... During the Cold war 1.0, the need to prevent their unjust use, our hands are dirty war place. In Vietnam impermissible—strategically, morally or otherwise make the rules proxies have greater reason to choose violence over.. €¦ ] the Korean war and the like of communist aggression Nixon ended all interventions... Minh declared all out war in 1969 most Americans came to define an.! War ’ s allies and interests in the crossfire a bad name the Tet Offensive attacking around 100 in... Providing great powers the opportunity to compete while avoiding direct confrontation that supplying weapons to a proxy with! With America’s role in Vietnam providing a prime example problem of dirty hands moral hazards use. The cambodian Civil war within South Vietnam were divided at the 17th.... Only a small portion of the policy of containment small portion of the conflict effects occurred the... For themselves and their benefactors greatest concern for the United States comes the! Great-Power competition grows, so does the appeal of proxy war often more so such as South! Risks for themselves and their benefactors why a country that had been barely known to most Americans came define! Such as the South was supported by communist countries such as the South who fought the. Died either in battle or as civilians caught in the crossfire later to! Tet Offensive attacking around 100 cities in Southern Vietnam due to the fire provision leads to greater deterrence not. The rules, it depends on what kind of world we want to be what... Where the United States and the rest of Southeast Asia in 1973 iran that proxy.